“Doe Season” is a taut, haunting initiation story. Unlike traditional coming-of-age narratives that celebrate a child’s entry into adult society, Kaplan’s story explores a more painful, ambiguous transition: the moment a young girl realizes she does not want the identity being forced upon her. The protagonist, nine-year-old Andrea “Andy” Kaplan (no relation to the author—a coincidental but notable same last name), goes on a deer hunt with her father and two older men. By the story’s end, she has not killed a deer but has killed something else: her father’s image of who she should be.